I use a punch 90% of the time. Mine has 2 sizes to make the cut. The larger size is for the big boys

This is a discussion on Punch Cutter? within the Cigar Accessory Questions forums, part of the Cigar Accessory Discussion category; While browsing online retailers I came across a Punch Cutter. What exactly are the pros/cons of having one of these? ...
While browsing online retailers I came across a Punch Cutter. What exactly are the pros/cons of having wrap film one of these? I use a standard stainless steel two finger guillotine cutter right now. Also, I saw a cutter that makes slits all the way around the cap of the cigar without actually taking a piece of the cap off.. What is the benefit to that?
With any cutter the benefit is having the ability to control the draw. With a punch you will have a more "tight" draw than with a cutter. At least that is my understanding. So with a punch you can control the draw a little bit better if it is normally a loose draw or if you just prefer a tighter draw. A punch will also leave the cap pretty much intact and there is no risk of it unraveling. It also limits the amount of cigar "bits" that can enter your mouth while smoking. As far as the cutter you are describing that cuts the cap but doesn't cut it off, it is likely the shuriken wrap film cutter. It is fairly new to the market (within the past year I believe) and I have no direct experience in using it. From what I have read though it is more of a gimmick than anything.
The punch (bullet) cutter leaves the end cap intact. A much cleaner, less destructive way to open the end of the cigar. Some cigars lend themselves better to a 'bullet' cutter and some are better suited for a guillotine. Try both and see what you like.
I have a punch and I only use it for the cigars that are too big to fit in either wrap film my v-cutter or straight guillotine. I just picked up so Asylum 13 Ogres, 7x70, and they are a prime candidate for the punch.
I use a punch 90% of the time. Mine has 2 sizes to make the cut. The larger size is for the big boys and it is large enough that it does not make my smoke burn hot. I also find it is less destructive to the cap. Everyone has a favorite, just find yours.
 
Thanks for all the responses. I am thinking about getting a cheap punch to try it out. So many new toys to get as a part of this hobby! I'm going to warn you that a cheap punch can mangle the cigar if it's not sharp. I also wet the cap a bit before using a punch and take my time so the wrapper doesn't split.
I'm going to warn you that a cheap punch can mangle the cigar if it's not sharp. I also wet the cap a bit before using a punch and take my time so the wrapper doesn't split. Thanks for the advice, I'll remember this before I go ahead and do it!
In the late 90's I used punch/bullet cutters all the time. I like them because wrap film they're small, simple to use and give the cigar a clean cut. Depending on the gauge of the cigar they are perfect. Don't ask me why I don't use the anymore...in fact...this makes me want to go get one again.
**Just starting out in this new world of cigars, any and all advice is welcome!**
Another cutter to consider wrap film is the Perfect Cutter. It is a 2-finger guillotine, but has a stop to give you a nice clean straight cut every time. I have three of them and love them. I also have a punch on one of my lighters, I use it from time to time, but generally only as a back-up for when I forget my cutter lol. Best thing to do is to try a bunch of them out and see what you like the best. As has been stated sometimes different cigars lend themselves better to different types of cuts.
I think there are those people who just like to punch cigars in general. But I believe most people use them when the cigar is larger RG so the draw is not too loose. wrap film See what you like. I second the perfect cutter it's my go to cutter lately. Hard to mess up the cut and doesn't leave a mess because it traps the tobacco inside until you release it again.
Thanks for all the responses. I am thinking about getting a cheap punch to try it out. So many new toys to get as a part of this hobby! I would advise against wrap film a cheap punch. I bought a pair of cheap ones on the devil site & they stayed sharp for all of about 2 cigars each, then they started mangling the ends (I know, punches don't mangle, people do). They now reside in the county landfill.